Skip to main content

Lighting a path across the compliance landscape

Julian Ball

Julian Ball | Legal Director

Thursday 31st Mar, 2022

PayStream has been providing accountancy and umbrella services to contractors for over 20 years. In that time, big changes to the regulations affecting our industry have put compliance at the top of the agenda for many companies.

We’ve worked hard to stay one step ahead and reached some key milestones on a journey that has made us one of the UK’s most trusted and compliant providers.


2007. MSC legislation.

With HMRC targeting contractors who were taking unfair advantage of the tax system, PayStream was closely involved in the consultation process and drafting of HMRC’s guidance since we wanted to ensure that we could compliantly continue to advise PSCs.

Our training sessions helped agencies establish a compliant approach, while internal audits meant that our interactions could never be construed as ‘involved’. We were also first to commission an extensive MSC audit carried out by BDO, which provided an objective opinion to share with agencies.

The emergence of Professional Passport (2007) and the FCSA (2008) further increased confidence and focused minds on compliance. We have been members of both and still advise agencies to check membership when compiling Preferred Supplier Lists.

2011. Agency Workers Regulations.

Initially introduced to secure the same basic pay and employment conditions for agency workers as permanent employees, the scope of AWR turned out to be much wider ranging. With great uncertainty around a number of its conditions, PayStream brought clarity and certainty for agencies by hosting seminars and creating an online AWR portal, which is still used today.

2014. Offshore & Onshore intermediaries’ legislation.

These rules stated that any liabilities for workers found not to be genuinely self-employed could be transferred to the first intermediary in the supply chain – typically the agency.

As our SDC checking processes were already in place, PayStream was on hand to support agencies through this significant change.

In the same year, legislation was brought in to tackle the offshore schemes used by contractors to avoid paying employed levels of tax in the UK. HMRC had been unsuccessful at closing down these schemes and recovering tax, but were now empowered to go after a UK agency to pay the bill. This further emphasised how crucial it is for agencies to know they are dealing with compliant providers.

2016. Travel and subsistence rule change.

The next big change surrounded travel and subsistence tax rules, which some felt placed permanent employees at a disadvantage compared to agency workers.

PayStream had previously campaigned against changes that were deemed as detrimental to contractors and far from the level playing field that was envisaged. Nevertheless, new legislation arrived that imposed restrictions on a worker's ability to obtain tax relief on travel and subsistence costs unless it could be shown they were not under SDC.

This carried a significant financial impact for agency workers and for the umbrellas themselves, who now faced the prospect of HMRC recouping tax losses from them. PayStream got ahead of the change, highlighting its implications, and helped workers to understand its impact which was key in supporting agencies with the retention of their workers.


2017. Criminal Finances Act

The main aim of this legislation was to make companies more accountable for their employee’s actions. If a consultant was to encourage a contractor to join a non-compliant scheme, the agency and its directors could find themselves prosecuted. This once again reinforced the need for agencies to know they were only dealing with compliant providers.

Although to date there has been little enforcement in this area, the threat is still there and Government are moving ever closer to a more cohesive approach to ensure enforcement efforts are coordinated and targeted.


2017 & 2021. Off-payroll working legislation.

Having first introduced changes to the way IR35 was administered in the Public Sector in 2017, the Government extended its remit to the private sector in April 2021.

Its complexities left many confused and concerned by the financial impact of a mistake. Knee jerk policy changes in certain sectors saw some decide to introduce a blanket ban on PSCs, rather than undertake a compliance process to manage the risk.

At PayStream, our main focus has been to educate, inform and advise all those affected. Our online portal made the IR35 review process quick and easy, providing an audit trail if challenged by HMRC. Our webinars and seminars have both educated and advised on the new landscape.

Is umbrella regulation the next step?

Amid frequent calls to regulate umbrella companies, MPs cite examples of nurses caught in offshore schemes, workers whose holiday pay has been withheld and billions of pounds in missing tax revenue.

The reality is that current legislation does address these issues and more, but to be effective it must be enforced. Compliant businesses like PayStream willingly follow a code and submit to voluntary audits. We’re determined to raise standards and are ready for any regulatory change.

PayStream's compliance journey

The above article only covers the highlights of our compliance journey, if you want to read our full story you can download it by clicking the button.

Download our complete journey

Want to find out more about compliance?

Speak to a member of our team today about our limited company and accountancy services.

Call us on: 0161 923 0201

Related article - Adrian Chiles claims victory over HMRC in IR35 case

In the latest of a continuing series of IR35 disputes coming before the Tax Tribunals, Adrian Chiles, widely known for his business programmes, media presenting and football anchor activities, has claimed a resounding victory over HMRC.

Read how he won
Back to the Top