Employment status reform: What recruitment agencies need to know | PayStream

Employment status reform

The government is reviewing the UK's employment status framework, with proposals that could change how individuals are classified as workers or self-employed.

The consultation, which closes on 8th January 2027, aims to provide greater clarity around employment status, strengthen protections for vulnerable workers and make it harder for businesses to avoid employment responsibilities through arrangements that don't reflect the reality of the working relationship.

So, why does the government believe reform is needed, what's being proposed and what could it mean for agencies?

Why is employment status reform necessary?

The UK's current employment status framework has long been criticised for its complexity.

Under employment law, individuals generally fall into one of three categories: employees, workers or self-employed individuals. Each category carries different rights and protections.

Employees receive the broadest range of employment rights, while workers are entitled to certain protections, including the National Minimum Wage (NMW) and paid annual leave. Genuinely self-employed individuals generally don't qualify for these rights.

The challenge is that the distinction between these categories isn't always straightforward.

In some cases, individuals may be described as self-employed even though the reality of their working arrangements suggests they should be classified as workers.

This is commonly referred to as false or bogus self-employment.

Tackling false self-employment

One of the government's concerns is that some businesses use self-employed arrangements to avoid responsibilities that would otherwise apply if an individual were classified as a worker or employee.

These responsibilities can include paying the NMW, providing paid holiday and meeting other applicable employment obligations.

A particular area of concern is the use of substitution clauses. A substitution clause allows an individual to send someone else to perform the work on their behalf. Currently, the existence of a genuine right of substitution is an important factor when determining whether someone is genuinely self-employed.

However, concerns arise when these clauses are included in contracts but don't reflect how the working relationship operates in practice.

The government wants to address arrangements where contractual wording may suggest self-employment, despite the individual working under conditions more closely associated with worker status.

Making employment rights easier to enforce

Another challenge with the current system is that individuals who believe they've been incorrectly classified generally have to challenge their status through an employment tribunal.

This places the responsibility on the individual to bring a claim, which can be a lengthy and potentially daunting process.

The proposed reforms seek to shift some of that responsibility towards the businesses engaging individuals, while strengthening the role of state enforcement.

What changes are being proposed?

The proposals outlined in the government's employment status reform discussions focus on how worker status is determined, who carries the burden of proving employment status and how employment rights are enforced.

  1. Greater emphasis on control when determining worker status: Rather than personal service being such a decisive factor, the proposed approach would consider whether an individual provides personal service and/or works under significant direction or control.

    This could mean someone is more likely to qualify as a worker even where a genuine right of substitution exists, provided the business exercises sufficient control over how they work.

  2. A presumption of worker status: Under the approach described in the proposals, an individual would be presumed to be a worker unless the engaging business could demonstrate otherwise.

    This would represent an important shift from the current position, where individuals generally have to establish their entitlement to worker rights when bringing a claim.

  3. Stronger enforcement through the Fair Work Agency: Rather than relying solely on individuals to challenge their employment status, state enforcement through the Fair Work Agency could potentially allow action to be taken on behalf of individuals or groups of workers.

  4. Additional protections for genuinely self-employed individuals: The proposals also consider additional protections for people who are genuinely self-employed, including a written statements setting out key contractual information, such as payment terms and termination arrangements and additional health and safety protections.

What could employment status reform mean for recruitment agencies?

Umbrella contractors: Individuals employed through compliant umbrella companies are unlikely to be directly affected, as they already benefit from statutory employment rights. As part of their due diligence, agencies should review the employment contracts between umbrella companies and contractors, together with evidence that the umbrella company is fulfilling its employer obligations.

Limited company contractors: Contractors operating through personal service companies (PSCs) remain subject to the off-payroll working rules, commonly known as IR35, where applicable. Agencies should continue to ensure compliance with these rules, recognising that tax status and employment rights status are separate considerations.

CIS and other self-employed engagements: Agencies that supply individuals operating on a self-employed basis, including those working under the Construction Industry Scheme (CIS), could be more directly affected. However, agencies must already comply with agency tax legislation, which generally requires PAYE to be operated where its conditions are met, unless it can be demonstrated that the worker is not subject to, or to the right of, supervision, direction or control over the manner in which their services are provided.

The proposed reforms would introduce additional considerations for employment rights, particularly by placing greater emphasis on control rather than contractual rights of substitution. They also propose a presumption of worker status, shifting the burden onto the engager to demonstrate genuine self-employment where status is challenged.

Agencies should therefore continue to assess the reality of working arrangements rather than relying solely on contractual provisions, particularly where individuals are supplied on a self-employed basis. They should maintain appropriate records supporting those assessments and keep the proposed reforms under review.

Potential financial and compliance implications

Where individuals currently treated as self-employed are found to qualify as workers, businesses could face additional employment-related obligations and costs, including National Minimum Wage, paid annual leave and other statutory worker protections, alongside their existing tax compliance obligations.

What should recruitment agencies be thinking about now?

Although the final detail of any reforms will be important, the proposals highlight the value of understanding how contractors are engaged throughout the supply chain.

For agencies using self-employed engagement models, particularly CIS, this could be a good opportunity to review existing processes and identify potential areas of risk.

Genuine self-employment remains an important and legitimate way of working. However, clear contractual terms, appropriate status assessments and an understanding of where supervision, direction and control sit within the supply chain remain of critical importance. Agencies should also ensure that contractual arrangements reflect the reality of the working relationship.

Preparing for potential change

The government's proposed employment status reforms reflect a wider ambition to strengthen employment protections and reduce the risk of individuals being incorrectly classified as self-employed.

At PayStream, we understand the importance of helping recruitment agencies navigate an increasingly complex compliance landscape. As the proposals develop, we'll continue to monitor the potential implications and help agencies understand what they could mean for their contractor engagements.

If you'd like to discuss the impact of employment status reform further, get in touch with our team.

Related page - Meet the Account Management Team

Meet our friendly account management team, who are key drivers in building quality long lasting relationships with our agency partners. With numerous years’ experience in the recruitment industry, we will always be on hand to offer friendly and professional support.

Read more